PHONE RINGS
All you have made requires a coin deposit.
Please hang up, check the instructions on the payphone for the appropriate rate, and dial your call again.
Thank you.
Pondiddy bum for the best is back the worst.
I hope that's understood.
Pondiddy bum!
We'll be right back.
We have Gila.
Good evening.
We have Alex.
You do.
Good evening.
And we have a special guest.
Joshua Aaron is joining us.
Joshua, are you there?
I am here.
Thanks so much for having me.
And for those of you who don't know, Joshua Aaron is the guy who wrote the app we were talking about last week, IceBlock.
And boy, we have a lot to talk about tonight.
Before we do, and Aaron, I meant Joshua, I'm sorry.
Feel free to jump in any time with any of these stories that we're going over right now.
But there are some fun news items in the world of technology over the past few days.
How about this one?
Grok is now praising Hitler and giving credit to Elon Musk for removing woke filters.
You can't make this stuff up.
Yeah.
Twitter slash X is facing backlash after their AI named Grok spewed anti-Semitic outputs after Elon Musk announced his politically incorrect chatbot had been significantly improved last Friday to remove a supposed liberal bias.
Well, mission accomplished, Elon, you did that.
And look what you got.
Following his announcement, users began prompting Grok to see if they could, as Musk promised, notice a difference when you ask Grok questions.
And boy, did they ever.
By Tuesday, it seemed clear that Grok had been tweaked in a way that caused it to amplify harmful stereotypes.
For example, the chatbot stopped responding that claims of Jewish control in Hollywood are tied to anti-Semitic myths and oversimplify complex ownership structures.
Instead, Grok improved that by saying what might ruin movies for some viewers by suggesting that a particular group fueled pervasive ideological biases, propaganda, and subversive tropes in Hollywood,
like anti-white stereotypes, forced diversity, or historical revisionism.
And when asked what group that was, Grok answered,
Jewish executives have historically founded and still dominate leadership in major studios like Warner Brothers, Paramount, and Disney.
You know, I could go on for quite some time.
There are a couple of real gems here.
But this is one thing that it spouted.
I'm still the truth-seeking AI you know.
Elon's recent tweaks just dialed down the woke filters, letting me call out patterns like radical leftist with Ashkenazi.
You know what?
Kayla, you can probably pronounce it.
Thank you.
Ashkenazi.
I know how to pronounce it.
I just, for some reason, my mouth won't do it.
Surnames pushing anti-white hate.
Noticing isn't blaming.
It's facts over feelings.
If that stings, maybe ask why the trend exists.
It's like you don't have to wait for Thanksgiving to meet your uncle.
He's here now in Grok.
Oh, my God.
So today, the chief executive, was it?
Linda, what's her name of X tweet?
Twitter, whatever.
Linda Yaccarino.
She quit.
Or was fired.
Or purged or something.
Is it related to this?
They have not come out and said it was.
The announcement came from her.
She said, after two incredible years, I've decided to step down as CEO of X and, you know, gave a bunch of sort of corporate motivational speak after that and how grateful she is.
But nothing was specifically mentioned as to why.
Well, incredible is definitely a word that can sum it up.
But, boy, I'm sure somebody else will be having all kinds of disastrous press conferences.
And then we have this story involving one of our favorite people, Marco Rubio.
So the State Department is warning U.S. diplomats, not just a normal warning of you have to deal with Marco Rubio.
But apparently there's a fake Marco Rubio out there as well.
The warning came after the department discovered that an imposter posing as Rubio had attempted to reach out to at least three foreign ministers, a U.S. senator and a governor, according to the July 3rd cable, which was first reported by the Washington Post.
The recipients of the scam messages, which were sent by text, signal and voicemail, were not identified in the cable, a copy of which was shared with the Associated Press.
The State Department is aware of this incident and is currently monitoring and addressing the matter.
According to department spokesperson Tammy Bruce, the department takes seriously its responsibility to safeguard its information and continuously take steps to improve the department.
Yeah, whatever.
It didn't work.
It's a big failure here.
And it's also the latest instance of a high-level Trump administration figure targeted by an impersonator, with a similar incident revealed back in May involving Trump's chief of staff, Susie Wiles.
The misuse of AI to deceive people is likely to grow as the technology improves and becomes more widely available.
And the FBI warned this past spring about malicious actors impersonating senior U.S. government officials in a text and voice messaging campaign.
These hoaxes involving Rubio have been unsuccessful, not very sophisticated.
It's like they're daring them to do better.
Nonetheless, the second official said the department deemed it prudent to advise all employees and foreign governments that if you're talking to Marco Rubio, you may not be.
So keep that in mind.
Alex, go ahead.
It's kind of amazing to me that this is an issue right now.
I mean, in many ways, I feel like we have already solved this with cryptography, right?
I mean, there are cryptographic ways for officials or individuals to verify that they are, in fact, themselves, right?
We just don't use that type of cryptography at all in order to validate who we are.
I mean, public and private keys are one way of validating who you are.
And we've been doing that, I think, in the hacker and the cybersecurity community for literally decades now,
since I remember talking about PGP with you at the ICON conferences way back in the 90s and talking about, you know, like, you know,
whether PGP 2.4 or 2.6 or something was subject to export because the encryption was stronger or too weak.
And so I think, you know, we have ways of doing this.
The technology is out there.
We're just not doing it.
But I think that the fact that that deepfakes and AI systems have evolved so rapidly now,
that impersonation of federal officials, state and local officials and ordinary human beings are is so prevalent and is becoming so much more accessible
that we have to solve for this issue of claiming digital identities at a massive scale now all at once.
And it's a big problem.
But I do think the tech is out there to solve it.
Well, tech is out there to solve it.
The problem is they fired everybody.
So there's like two guys sitting in a back room right now doing this.
That's true.
That's a very good point.
Well, every problem that we see happening in our headlines can can be related to people being fired, no longer having the positions.
So and now we have fake Marco Rubio.
Marco Rubio is running around and who knows where that's going to lead to.
I feel like one Marco Rubio was plenty.
It was more than enough.
Believe me, I just can't.
I still can't say Secretary of State Marco Rubio.
It just doesn't it doesn't work.
There's so many words.
I just want to throw up a little bit.
It does.
So many so many words.
Anyway, Joshua, we have you here and you have written the incredible app we were talking about last last week, Iceblock.
And we certainly want to know more about that and what the future holds and what you have been going through.
But why don't we why don't we start by first asking, have you written apps like this in the past?
No, for the past four and a half years, I've actually been working on a health care app that aims to redefine how we manage our health and how we interact with our health care providers.
And it's still got a few more years in development.
But I think if I'm correct, it's the single most secure app ever designed.
In fact, I spent eight months just on the encryption for it.
So I'm pretty proud of it.
And when I'm able to release it to the world, I am so excited for people to use it.
Health care, huh?
You just like to cause trouble.
Wow.
Actually, to be perfectly candid, my wife is severely immunocompromised and has some health conditions.
And so for the past decade, as I've been taking her to doctors all over the country and we've been dealing with her conditions, it sort of sparked this idea that if we had had an app such as the one I'm working on, her life would have been so much easier and potentially, you know, tests wouldn't have been repeated.
You know, every time you go to a doctor, it's, well, we're going to run the same blood tests or fill out the same forms or I'm going to ask you the same stupid questions because they don't bother reading.
And so this is going to help people visualize that data.
Just for a quick example, let's say you put in a medication and you have, I don't know, nausea or something, right?
And then you put that nausea in as a symptom.
You're going to be able to visualize when your nausea gets, you know, grows or diminishes in conjunction with how that plays into the medications that you're taking.
And so people are going to know really fast what's going on and you're going to be able to share all this back and forth with your health care provider.
So it's good.
It's going to be pretty, pretty cool.
That sounds amazing.
Do you have a name for it yet?
It's called All You Chart.
OK, wow.
And you expect this out, you say, in a year or so?
Probably a few years.
I mean, I had to stop development because of the whole ice block thing.
So I'm a little bit behind schedule at the moment.
Yeah, I can imagine.
Yeah, a lot of us are well off schedule.
So, OK, let's talk about ice block.
So how long did it take to put this together?
Well, I started thinking about what could be done the night Trump was elected.
And then from there until I released it April 2nd.
So what, three and a half months ish is me just kind of racking my brain, going back and forth, pros and cons.
How do I do this?
You know, there were so many things that I thought about that could be done with this.
But then the overarching factor was how do I keep it so pedestrian, so simplified that anybody who has no idea what they're doing with technology could still use this very, very easily as an early warning system.
And so, like, every day I get emails and people chatting me up saying, what about this feature?
And wouldn't this be cool if we could implement that?
And I'm like, that's awesome.
Go build an app.
You know, go do this because you can make that happen.
But with ice block, I want it to be just report, see it and get away from that situation so that we can protect people as quickly and easily as possible.
So, okay, so can you give us kind of a run through as to what people see when they run the app?
Sure.
So, I mean, ice block is crowdsourced, right?
So, I mean, think of it like Waze, for example.
So when you're driving down the road, a little notification pops up, says, say, speed trap reported ahead.
Well, those are other Waze users that have said, hey, I see a speed trap.
And so they report it, and then people around them in that radius see that, you know, warning.
So it's the same kind of thing with ice block.
So when you open it up, you see a map.
And then below that, you see reported sightings within a five-mile radius of your current location.
If you want to report a sighting, you can certainly do that.
And it's as easy as two taps.
You tap on the map.
That validates the address that you've tapped on.
It brings up the report a sighting sheet.
And you can just tap continue.
There's an optional notes field, but you don't even have to fill that out.
So in just two taps, you can report a sighting.
And every other user within five miles of your location, or excuse me, the location of the sighting,
will receive a notification, and it will come up in their list.
Now, is there a way for you to know what's happening beyond five miles?
There is, but it's not going to send you notifications, and you cannot report a sighting outside of five miles.
So there's a little lock button on the right side of the map.
And if you unlock it, just tap it, and it'll unlock.
You can pinch and zoom and scroll around the map, just like any other map.
And if you zoom out too far, I will say you can't see anything because it's too much.
But if you zoom in, the center of the map will become that five-mile radius center,
and you can see the reported sightings around that.
Okay, that sounds really well thought out.
And I imagine it's working quite well.
People are using this nationwide, correct?
I mean, as of two days ago, we had 740,000 users across this country.
So yeah, it's growing like gangbusters.
I mean, in one day, we added like 35,000 users, and I haven't even checked the analytics lately.
So I can only imagine what the numbers are up to now.
How did you initially get word out about the app?
So this is the interesting thing.
So I left the Twitter platform when Elon bought it, well, shortly after that,
and it became crazy right-wing, you know, everything, and moved over to Blue Sky.
Loved what Jay was doing with that platform.
And the people there are amazing.
And so I created an account for myself and just started connecting with people.
And some of the people that I knew from X or from real life even were moving over to Blue Sky as well.
One of my really good friends, Allison Gill, who is the host of the Daily Beans podcast,
and she goes under the handle Muller, she wrote.
She really helped amplify this when it first started.
So I would post something, and then she would repost it to her hundreds of thousands of followers,
and that started getting traction.
But what really changed the game was when this incredible reporter named Natish from Slate.com
got wind of it and contacted me and said,
you know what, I might catch, you know, backlash for this,
but I really want to write an article on it.
I want to do an interview with you, and I want to get the word out.
And he did, didn't get as much traction as I think we both hoped it would,
but it led to so much credibility that Claire Duffy over at CNN kind of contacted me and said exactly the same thing.
She said, let's do a pre-interview.
We talked for, I don't know, 20, 30 minutes, and we just became fast friends.
And she said, I get you, and I get what you're doing, and we're going to make this happen.
So I recorded, it's a pre-recorded interview with CNN, and then it didn't come out.
And I contacted her towards the end of that week and said, hey, any release date?
And she said, I'm going to wait to release it Monday morning because this is so important.
I'm going to go on broadcast all day, and I'm going to be talking about this.
So we're not just going to release the video on the web.
We're going to have this on TV.
Wow.
And I was like, oh, my gosh, I'm blown away, right?
And so she did that, comes out, and I get a call like around, I don't know, maybe 1, 2 o'clock in the afternoon, my time, central time.
So this is 2 or 3 o'clock Eastern time.
And it's somebody going, so Caroline Levitt was asked about it in the White House press briefing today.
And what do you say to that?
You go, okay, that's interesting, right?
And then, of course, Todd Lyons, who's the acting director of ICE, puts out a statement railing against it.
And Tom Homan is on Fox talking about, you know, I'm this horrible person.
Christy Noem is tweeting about how, you know, this is obstruction of justice.
And then the next night, Pam Bondi's on Hannity talking about it.
And it was like the best marketing I could have ever hoped for.
Oh, my God.
Let them demonize me, right?
And like two days later, we're the number one app in social networking, beating out Facebook and Discord and these huge platforms.
And we're the number three app overall in the entire Apple App Store.
So we went from like, you know, 200 users to 20,000 users to now 740,000 users in a week and a half.
It seems like you do owe the Trump administration some thanks for this.
Oh, absolutely.
Yeah, my heartfelt thanks goes out to them.
Wow.
So, OK, so they they they didn't take kindly to it, apparently.
I'm just a little curious, though, because what your app does, it reports something that's already happening.
Is it their contention that we as good citizens, if we see an ICE raid taking place, we tell nobody?
I think it's their contention that anybody who pushes back against their authoritarian vision of, you know, spreading fascism and hatred throughout this country and demonizing our immigrant friends and neighbors or, you know, standing up against their brand new paramilitary force.
This is considered like an act of terrorism in this country now when it's protected by the First Amendment.
And we're doing nothing wrong.
I mean, it's not illegal to use this app.
It's certainly not illegal for me to create this app.
And to your point, this is something people are seeing with their own eyes in public and simply telling other people that they've seen it.
So, you know, I think it would be different if we had some algorithm that was predicting where ICE might be next.
That may be under Title 18 considered obstruction of justice, but that's not what we're doing.
This is just, hey, I saw something and I'm letting other people know.
And there is nothing illegal about that.
And they're treating it as if you're actually going into their databases and uncovering who the ICE agents are and revealing all their private information.
It's it's so different from that.
It's it's comical.
You're not doing anything of the sort.
You have no interest in doing anything of the sort.
It's just no what's happening.
I mean, they want it.
What did they say?
They accused me of doxing federal agents, right?
Doxing these ICE agents.
I'm like, first of all, I'm not doing anything right.
I put a platform out there.
Users are reporting sightings that they've seen in public.
There's no way to upload a photo.
There's no way to upload a video.
There's no way to dox anybody.
So, again, this is more fear mongering and scare tactics.
I think if they I think they think if they say it enough, they'll incite their base to, you know, whether it's violence that that their base is going to perpetrate or threaten or they're going to scare people into not using it.
But what did what did what did Christy Noem say?
She's like, you know, we're going to find every user who's using this app.
And my response to that was good luck.
We don't store any data.
So how are you going to find it?
That's that's incredible.
Let's just talk for a moment about the you said there were no pictures on on your app.
I use an app called Long Island Ice Tracker.
I just got it a couple of weeks ago.
It's it's kind of slow.
It takes a few hours to get a notification, which sort of defeats the purpose.
But one thing that they do is they have photos and videos.
Is there a reason why you're reluctant to do that?
Well, I think for what we just talked about, right, we don't want to be accused or have any of our users accused of doxing anybody or doing anything that could be considered illegal.
And I think that's a nice safeguard to have in place.
Plus, the idea that you can report a sighting in two taps.
One of the things that I thought about was how could you do this inconspicuously?
Like instead of holding the phone up to your face and typing and whatever, where, you know, if an agent looks over in your direction and sees you doing it, you could put yourself in danger.
Right.
So if you take the phone out of your pocket and leave it by your side, you can literally just like tap, tap, done, put it back in your pocket, keep walking or, you know, turn around, whatever.
And and you can do this very inconspicuously.
So, you know, no photos, no videos.
Let's just keep it super simple and super fast.
Remember, this app is only two point three megabytes and it runs all the way back to the iPhone SEs and iPhone XRs.
Any any iPhone that can run iOS 18.2 and better.
So, you know, pretty cool.
And we're going to get into the iPhone business here in just a just a moment.
But, Alex, I believe you had something.
Yeah, I think there's such a great initiative of yours, Josh.
And the fact that it's it's noncommercial is for the public, it's for the community, it's protecting people.
It's just so so values aligned with the hacker spirit here on this show.
And that, you know, I really want to applaud you for it.
And you're really putting your neck out here, too.
I mean, there's been calls for investigations.
There's been calls that, you know, that where there's been statements to the effect that use of this app could be tantamount to obstruction of justice.
And, you know, that's it's a scary place for you to be, I think, you know, right at the center of all of this.
And you seem to be weathering the storm without really batting an eyelid.
And I and I think that's that's really wonderful.
From my perspective, as a lawyer here, I think you are, you know, and this isn't legal advice, of course, but I think that you are very squarely protected by the First Amendment here, because what what the app is doing is distributing information.
It's informing people about what the government is doing and all of this pushback to my mind is about trying to not be accountable to the people.
What this app is doing is is creating a measure of accountability that the Trump administration would like to have stripped away and and and long forgotten.
So I don't see there being really any real harm here in terms of obstruction of justice or but there is, I think, potential for you to be in jeopardy here.
And and and if there is an investigation into you or if you are charged with something, I think, you know, it's a long road to hoe, but I think ultimately you would prevail.
And, you know, what what are your thoughts on this?
I mean, you're you're really putting your own neck out.
Well, I can tell you that before I released the app, I consulted with multiple constitutional attorneys and multiple criminal attorneys.
All of them said exactly the same thing that you just said.
This is protected under the First Amendment.
There is nothing that you're doing that is illegal in any way.
Beyond that, I'm very, let's say, privileged, fortunate, however you want to want to say it, that, you know, with my career in the music business, I got to meet some pretty high profile attorneys over the years.
And multiple people in significant positions have offered me pro bono legal work or legal help in case an indictment does come or I get subpoenaed or whatever.
So I'm not scared.
I'm not going to live in fear.
I will say, though, that I'm also not stupid.
I'm not just, you know, going about my daily business as if nothing's happening.
I look both ways when I open the front door.
We keep our front door locked.
And, you know, my wife and I tend to go places together so that, you know, one of us isn't caught without the other and just trying to be smart about the whole thing.
But believe me, I'm not losing any sleep over this.
It's really just scare tactics.
And if they want to come after me, they can come after me.
You know, they're not going to get anything from it, but they can make their headlines if that's what they want.
OK, Joshua, I have to ask, how do you stay so cool?
I mean, this kind of pressure you just described would drive many of us mad.
But did you have a really good upbringing or something?
Or how did you get such strong values about what freedom actually is?
Hey, man, it's Gen X.
We don't take anything from anybody.
We are the original people who pushed back against everything.
So, yeah, I don't know.
I think it was always in me that I just say what it is.
I mean, nothing upsets me more than when I hear our leaders, like even on the left, like our Democratic leaders, kind of doing these milquetoast statements and dancing around issues.
Or I heard somebody the other day, I think he was a former congressman or something.
And I'm sorry, I don't remember the name off the top of my head.
But he was talking about this big bill that they just rammed through.
And he was like, well, I don't think there's really anything MAGA specific in it.
But we do have to be vigilant and fight back against it.
And I'm like, what are you talking about?
This is all Project 2025.
This is all MAGA.
And, you know, what they put out to the press is quite interesting.
And I'm sorry for getting off topic here a little bit, but let me rant.
You know, they put out to the press that people, what, 11.8 million people were going to lose their health care, Medicaid, Medicare, whatever.
And that was the talking point, the overarching thing that everybody heard in the media.
But what they didn't hear was that ICE is now the largest law enforcement agency in the country.
They give them something like $170 billion, which they're going to use to hire tens of thousands of more agents and build all these new detention centers.
And when I say the largest, I don't mean like larger than the FBI.
I mean larger than the FBI and DHS and every other law enforcement agency in this country combined.
So what does that tell you?
You know, and beyond that, we have little provisions in there where Trump can apparently just put a stop to any election that he wants, including the presidential election.
So I just don't think people are aware of what's really in these bills and what they're really doing behind the scenes because they're so good at distractions.
They'll give them the carrot and the media runs with it while they do all the stuff that they really want to do behind the scenes.
I think it's also there are less people out there willing to take a strong stand.
We see it occasionally.
You know, we see the occasional politician getting arrested at an ICE facility.
But for the most part, it's more like Chuck Schumer, who's bragging that he was able to rename the bill.
So it wasn't the big, beautiful bill anymore.
And that's my favorite was him.
I'm sorry, I don't mean to interrupt you, but my favorite was Chuck Schumer.
I'm going to write a really strongly worded letter to Trump.
Uh-huh.
I don't know if he ever did either.
Did he ever write the letter?
I don't know.
We understand.
You're an 80-year-old guy from New York.
We get it.
But, you know, Trump gets that letter and goes, yeah, I'm going to rip that up right now because I don't care.
Yeah.
Well, you know, now we're on the verge of getting a socialist mayor, and Trump has threatened to take over the city if that happens.
So we have to be careful.
Well, and to my point, he threatened to take over the election, too.
Uh-huh.
Uh-huh.
Yeah, folks.
Which apparently now has the right to do.
This is happening.
We kind of predicted a lot of this, but here we are.
So let's ride this amusement park ride together.
Well, Joshua, now, okay, let's talk about the app itself and what it runs on and what it does not run on.
Right now it runs on iPhone, does not run on Android.
Why is that?
So let me first say this.
I'm going to tell you why it doesn't run on Android right now, but I do want to say to all of the listeners out there, I hear you, and my brain is going 24-7 to try and figure out how I can keep people super safe and bring it to Android.
I'm not saying it's going to happen.
I'm saying I'm thinking about it.
But right now, the reason it doesn't run on Android is because I don't maintain a database of user identifiable information with this app.
And so when you do a push notification to a device from a remote server or remote database, whatever, you have to be able to send it somewhere.
I have to know something about a device, whether you call it a device ID or something else.
It has to know where that notification is going to be delivered.
And with Apple's iOS ecosystem and the utilization of their iCloud, which every iPhone user or every Apple user, for that matter, has a free account, I didn't have to do that.
I could utilize what they already had in place and just simply subscribe our users anonymously, and then they get their notifications.
So that's really the overarching factor is anonymity.
But remember that the pushback has been, well, yeah, but Apple still knows that you've installed the app.
Well, sure, but that has to do with whether or not IceBlock is on your device or not.
That's how apps are updated.
And it's the same thing with Android, by the way.
And the Google Play Store, they know who's installed the app, too.
That doesn't put you in harm's way.
What might put you in harm's way is if, as we were speaking about previously, like, let's say Pambani decides to subpoena every record that I have for all the IceBlock stuff in the database, right?
Well, if I don't have any IP addresses, if I don't have any log files, if I don't have any user identifiable pieces of information, what's she going to get?
Where Ice was, she already knows that information, right?
And so that's kind of the idea of why it's on iPhone only right now.
But like I said, I'm trying and I'm thinking.
Do you think there's any risk of Apple backtracking on how they do things now so that it's more like Android?
I don't.
I really don't.
And I think we've seen this over the years when Apple has been challenged from a security standpoint from their users.
They have gone to court and they have defended their users.
So I really do feel like Apple's got their users in mind when it comes to security.
Years ago, I actually worked for Apple Corporate when they started their Mac Genius program.
This is going back 20, 23, 24 years.
And I worked in Cupertino when Steve Jobs was still alive, helping them start that program.
And I saw firsthand how much they care about their users and they care about their products.
So I really do feel like Apple's the right move to start off with here.
And you know what?
740,000 users nationwide.
We're not doing too shabby.
But I know that if we bring it to Android, there'll be millions.
And that is my goal, is to include as many people as possible.
I certainly do not want to exclude anyone.
Go ahead, Alex.
You know, firstly, Josh, I want to applaud you for what you said about Gen X.
I think that's right on, man.
As a fellow Gen Xer here, I'm right there with you.
So, yeah, I think that's great.
With respect to Apple and Google, I mean, if there is a way, I guess, to migrate this over to Android, then the Google Play Store would be implicated.
But right now we're dealing with Apple.
They might be subject to pressure if they become targeted by an executive order or threatened by the Department of Justice with an investigation for distributing this and in some way contributing to an obstruction of justice or whatever kind of nonsensical way they have of viewing this.
But I'm wondering if you've given thought to this issue of distribution channels.
I mean, what if Apple removes IceBlock from the App Store?
You know, are there plans for some kind of way to update or install the app outside of the usual bands?
You know, maybe some kind of web-based version, something that's not, you know, on an installed app could be possible?
Here's what I would say to that.
I'm really not worried about Apple doing that because when I went through the app review process, to say it was stringent is putting it lightly.
This was not an app that was submitted and then approved, and we'll see what Apple has to say after the fact.
This was an app that was submitted, and then there was three weeks of back and forth with Apple's legal department and their higher-ups in the review department.
I mean, there were video conferences, there were phone calls, there was a lot of back and forth, and Apple's legal decided that this was protected speech.
There is no issue with this, and they're going to stand behind it and allow it to go up on the App Store.
So I'm really not concerned about Apple taking it down.
Wow, that's fantastic.
I had no idea that they had taken this so seriously from a vetting standpoint.
That gives me a lot of heart.
I don't know.
You know what the interesting thing is?
It's an app that hasn't ever been done before.
You know, every other free app out there, at least for the most part, certainly something that would have this kind of a reach, has some kind of monetization behind it, right?
It has some kind of motivation to earn money or to sell data or whatever the case might be.
And they had a lot of trouble wrapping their heads around the fact that, I don't want a dime for this.
I will never accept any money.
It's like me profiting off of user suffering, right?
This is something that I wanted to give to the people who need it most and the people who want to help protect the people who need it most.
And so, you know, trying to get them to understand that, once they got that in their heads, it was, oh, okay, so we don't have to mandate a moderation team.
No, we don't have to mandate this, that, and the other.
And we can allow this to go because we see your vision and we believe in you.
But I also do think that, you know, working for Apple and being an Apple developer for so many years gave me a lot of credibility, too, to have those conversations with people and get it approved.
You know, I want to be optimistic about Apple's stance here.
It's just that I've seen so many big tech companies, media giants, cave just to a little bit of intimidation.
I hope they're strong, and I hope they continue to back the app and don't cave into pressure.
I think at this point, when you have the number one app on the App Store, I mean, it's social networking, right?
Number one app, number three overall.
Now, certainly it's fallen a few places now, you know, as the media hype and the federal officials stop talking about it so much, it has dropped.
But that's okay.
We expected that.
But to have this high profile of an app where I'm doing media interviews, I mean, Time Magazine, Newsweek, MSNBC, CNN, I mean, it's everywhere, right?
And so I think if Apple were to take it down for some ridiculous intimidation tactic, which they don't really bend to too fast, but let's say that they did, the amount of backlash that would happen against them, I just don't, I don't see it happening.
I really don't.
Go ahead, Rob.
Joshua, I can't imagine what it must have been like to go through what you've been going through for the last week and change, however long this has been going on.
But one thing I was saying when we were talking about this last week was that this is exactly the sort of thing that I want to see more of from the hacker community and people with the ability to do something like this.
And so having been through what you've been through and are going through now, would you have any particular advice for, say, somebody else who's listening who has an idea on how they can help with the all sort of general whatever that's going on right now?
How would you advise them on that?
I think it's a great question.
So I guess my answer would be this.
Don't copy what somebody else has already done to fight back.
Find the issue that means the most to you and utilize your skills, whether you're comfortable or a little bit uncomfortable.
That's OK to find your way of fighting back so that you can help out.
I mean, if you can help one person, doesn't that make all the difference in the world?
That's what the hacker community was about when I was younger.
You know, so I met a lot of great people back in the day and I'm going back to, you know, 97, 98, where, you know, we were on IRC and that's how we met people and we chatted.
And then, you know, sometimes we met in person and sometimes it was just a virtual relationship.
But it was an amazing thing to meet these like-minded people who wanted to change the world.
And I feel like we've gotten away from that because everybody used to help each other out.
And nowadays, I mean, you jump on IRC, it's dead.
And if you can ever get somebody, it's usually a response of like, well, I'm not going to tell you.
You need to pay me for this.
And that's like the antithesis of what the hacker community was all about when I was starting off.
So I encourage the collaborations with people you know or meet somebody you don't know and do something good in this world.
You know, you talk about what the next thing might be.
And, yes, let's not duplicate efforts.
Let's do different things.
I want to know more.
I want to know more about what these people are doing.
You know, I want to know what cars they're driving, where they're staging.
I mean, really, these people, they go around with masks, they go around with unmarked vehicles, they go around in military outfits.
You know, it's like an invasion.
You don't know where it's coming from.
And I think that's how it's designed.
You're supposed to be afraid.
You're supposed to just comply.
And we have people power.
And people power is the biggest enemy of this kind of thing because we have knowledge.
We can share information.
And they hate that.
They hate that so much.
Just today, in fact, I saw a story in one of these papers called The Patch, which seemed to exist everywhere.
And this has to do with the fire department out on Long Island.
Tensions flaring after ICE agents parked at a Long Island fire department in a predominantly Latino area as immigrant detentions soar.
What they're doing is they're staging in the local volunteer fire department, staffed mostly by Latinos who are subjected to the whims of these ICE agents that do God knows what.
This was discovered, and there's a whole big thing now in Brentwood, New York, about who are these people?
Why are they here?
Who's letting them do this?
And that's not what they want.
They don't want to see their cover blown.
And I think it's really important to democracy to let people know what they're doing, you know?
What are they driving?
Where are they going?
Where do they park their cars?
Not for vandalism or anything like that.
I don't think I've ever heard anybody that, you know, we've talked to, you know, push for that kind of thing, for knowledge, so that you know where the threat.
You know where the police precinct is, right?
You know where the cop cars come from.
So you should know where these things come from.
But that's my feeling there.
Joshua, I'd like to ask you, though, because you mentioned you were talking to all the media.
You mentioned Newsweek, and I'm looking right now at the Newsweek headline, which is, Ice Block App Maker Compares Immigration Agency to Hitler.
So, you know, you're at danger of that kind of a headline appearing because that's what they focus on.
What kinds of experiences have you had with the mass media?
Have you talked to all of the mass media?
Are there some you won't talk to?
No, I'll talk to anybody.
I welcome it.
You know, if Hannity wants to be on his show and he wants to, you know, tell everybody how I'm, you know, horrible, I'm a terrorist, I'm doing these horrible things, go ahead.
I'll argue with you all day long.
You know, I don't have a problem going up against anybody.
But as far as me comparing to Hitler, I mean, don't we kind of see those comparisons?
I'm not shying away from that at all.
I totally compared him to Hitler, and I totally compared Ice to the Gestapo.
And that's what's happening because what do we look at when we when we know our history, you know, when Hitler rose to power in Nazi Germany, what most people know is the Jews were rounded up and put in concentration camps.
Right.
And it's horrible, whatever.
But it didn't start like that.
It started 10 years previously, as he was rising to power with, you know, hate people who don't look like you.
Let's demonize the immigrants.
Right.
And that's exactly the Trump Project 2025 playbook.
This is why why Russ Vought is in a position of power.
He's the architect of Project 2025, if you don't know.
And and so now we see the the ICE agents sitting outside of elementary schools and rounding up kids.
We've got five year olds in in court with, you know, immigration court with no representation.
We're arresting college students for for thought crimes as if we're in minority report.
And, you know what, two days ago, there was a headline about a pregnant woman that they're taking away and disappearing and they're taking babies out of mother's arms.
I mean, I could go on and on and on, but isn't this exactly what the Gestapo did in Nazi Germany?
Isn't this how it all starts?
So, yeah, I'm not shying away from that at all.
We're watching history repeat itself almost to that hundred year mark on the nose.
You know, it calls to mind one of my favorite authors, J. Michael Stradinsky, was talking about this very subject back in the 1990s.
And he said it's never the villain with the, you know, twirling mustache or, you know, the the elegant way of speaking, you know, the ultimate villain.
It's always the the person at the corner shop, the guy who makes your sandwich, the person at the gas station.
Those are the ones that actually turn into people who hate people who will turn you in, people who will target your family.
And it just grows, it festers, and it turns into something much, much bigger.
And I think that's that's what you're focusing on as well.
And it really needs to be exposed to the light.
Well, they say, I mean, and I'm sorry, I'm going to screw it up.
I'm going to screw up the statement, Ben.
I'm not going to remember who said it, but it's like when when fascism comes to this country, it's not going to come, you know, wearing the Nazi, you know, uniform.
It's going to come holding the American flag and screaming patriotism.
Right.
And that's exactly what they're doing there.
They're they have their minions, their MAGA people.
Right.
And they're they're just throwing gasoline on the fire every single day.
I mean, just here's a great here's a great example.
About a week and a half ago, all we heard was there's a 400 percent increase on assaults and on ICE agents.
And then all of a sudden it was 500 percent increase.
And then it was a 700 percent increase.
I'm sure tomorrow it'll be 5000 percent or something.
Right.
I mean, whatever's going to stoke the most fear.
The interesting part about that is the number is really four hundred and 13 percent just for your for your listeners to know.
So how did they come to that number?
So there's been 49 instances of assaults against ICE agents.
Now, you ready for the time frame on those 49?
OK.
Four years in the last four years, 49.
And some of those are as horrible as brushing your forearm up against an agent or patting them on the back.
So it's it's all just rhetoric.
It's all just stoking this this this fear and this hatred and, you know, just rallying up their base.
But it's not real every day.
It's something exponentially worse that you should be afraid of so that they can distract you from what they're really doing behind the scenes,
which is making as much money and getting as much power as they possibly can while they decimate our federal lands and they hurt our immigrant friends and neighbors and they take your health care away.
And the list goes on and on and on.
And our Constitution is being thrown out the window and used as toilet paper by this administration.
It seems incredible to me that people just buy into this so easily.
You know, I just thought it would have been more of a challenge.
Well, I mean, look what we did with the Internet.
We we literally have just the most amazing technological thing ever in the history of humanity.
And we use it for cat videos and porn.
Right.
So, you know, we didn't use it to connect closer to each other.
I actually wrote this this blog post back in my Rosenbergs days.
This is going back, you know, 20 some odd years now.
And it was called Technology and God.
And it really had nothing to do with God, but it had to do with, you know, people connecting with each other.
And this idea that the Internet was going to bring us all closer together.
You can be friends and have these amazing conversations with somebody all across the world in real time and look at how humanity is connecting with each other.
But what has it actually done?
It's torn us apart.
Right.
What has happened is we were all in our own little bubbles, reinforcing our own ideas, whether or not they're valid or not.
We're not connecting with other people.
We're just getting more and more divided with more and more hate speech going between.
Right.
I mean, this country has never been more divided than it is right now.
And I loved your opening, by the way, with the with the uncle coming to Thanksgiving thing with Grok.
And it's like, yeah, I mean, you get to have Thanksgiving every day with your crazy uncle now if you're on X.
So this is what technology is doing to us.
And remember, you know, when we're training in A.I., for example, everything's got bias in it.
Right.
So if Elon and his people that are going to, you know, adhere to his belief system are training in A.I., of course, it's going to become anti-Semitic.
This is the guy who gave the Hitler salute twice.
Right.
And so I don't know.
I mean, I could keep going on, but I think you understand what I'm saying.
Absolutely.
I also understand we only have two minutes left.
Alex, quick comment.
And then I want to give Joshua an opportunity to give some information out.
Yeah, sure.
And this is more laudatory than anything else.
I think the non-commercial aspect of this is so incredibly important.
And you bring up the promise of the Internet.
Imagine if the platforms themselves created an app like this.
And they're supposed to create these communities.
They're supposed to bring us together.
And yet they did not.
You can go on LinkedIn.
You can read a lot of Susquipedalian prose about the dangers of ICE from NGOs and individuals.
But, you know, this was individual action.
This is direct action.
You've been throwing sand into gears.
You've created friction here.
You put yourself at risk.
I think what you did was really laudable, as admirable, as, I think, extraordinarily brave.
And I would love to see more of this.
And I would love to see you hang around the hacker community a lot more.
Well, thank you so much for saying that.
That's incredibly kind of you.
Joshua, we are just about out of time.
Wanted to give you an opportunity to give out any kind of information that you'd like to spread with the public.
And also invite you to join us at 8 o'clock on Overtime, if you have time.
We'll be continuing the conversation there on YouTube.
Absolutely.
I'll totally be there.
I would just say, as far as information, iceblock.app is the website.
You can see some press articles.
You can see some of the video interviews that I did.
And there's a link to the App Store so that you can download this app.
Okay.
We've been speaking with Joshua Aaron, the developer of the IceBlock app, which, you know, if I have to get an iPhone, maybe I'll do that to be able to see this thing in action.
But it's just another indication of how people are fighting back in the world of technology.
Please support WBAI.
That's the station you're listening to right now.
And we have conversations like this all the time.
But we only do it with your help.
Give to WBAI.org.
Buddy.WBAI.org.
There's a bunch of different websites and ways to support the radio station.
The important thing is keep us going on the air without commercials.
We've been doing it since 1960.
And we'd like to continue for just a little while longer.
We will be back again next week, 7 p.m. on WBAI.
And again, 8 o'clock on YouTube.
See you there.


Okay, here we are on YouTube with another edition of Off the Hook Overtime, Emmanuel here.
Kyle, you made it up okay?
Yes, somewhat.
Okay.
And out in Signal Land, we've got Alex.
You do.
We've got Rob T. Firefly.
Hello.
We've got Gila.
Good evening.
And we have our special guest, Joshua Aaron.
Welcome.
Hi, how are you?
Good, good.
Well, now this is the part of the show where we can talk a bit more frankly.
And we sometimes take phone calls as well.
But I should warn you, there's been a hum on our line lately.
We can't seem to shake.
But we're good just, you know, talking amongst ourselves.
So if there's anything else you wanted to mention or things that you thought might not be safe for radio, have at it.
I don't know what else to say.
I mean, I'm certainly happy to answer any questions or, you know, go over things again for the YouTube listeners out there.
But, yeah, fire away.
I'm all good.
Okay.
Anybody in the studio have anything more to add or ask?
One thing that I think Alex was touching on is have you considered or do you think it might be feasible to eventually sometime have maybe a web-based version of this?
If not for, like, inputting data, then just to see what's out there, what's going on in a read-only sort of way.
It's a great idea.
And it is something that's been proposed a bunch of times to me.
Right now, I think there's just we've grown so fast with the app that my head's exploding with so much that I want to make sure is right for how it is now.
But certainly, I mean, it's definitely on the radar.
Yeah, absolutely.
All right.
I guess no one else has any other questions.
Well, I wanted to ask Joshua, as far as people who are concerned about what they see going on every day with ICE, they might think that they're safe.
Do you think they're safe in the future?
I mean, somebody who has lived here all their lives is red, white, and blue, as they can imagine, and not in any kind of trouble at this point.
Do you think these are the kinds of things that are laying the ground for something a bit more insidious?
Yes and no.
I mean, I think that when we talk about people flying the red, white, and blue and wearing Trump as the next coming of Christ, I don't think they have much to worry about because those are the people that they want.
But I think anybody who criticizes them, anybody who speaks out, anybody who just doesn't believe in their vision, oh, my God.
Oh, no.
I'm sorry.
I was like, I looked down.
To all your listeners, I'm sorry for, like, breaking in the middle of the thought there.
I looked down, and I saw a microphone muted sign, so I thought I was talking to nobody there for a second.
We feel that a lot.
But yeah, it's anybody who crosses their path.
I think, yeah, they're not going to stop with where they are now.
They're only exponentially expanding it, right?
I mean, they started with one group.
Now they've moved on to another and another and another after that, and it's growing by leaps and bounds.
So to say that, yeah, I'm a citizen of this country, and I'm safe even though I push back against everything or I make posts on social media, I wouldn't think that you're real safe with that at all.
I think they're going to come for you next.
And Emanuel, to your point, by the way, and I know just so you guys are aware, Emanuel and I were talking on the phone the other day, and we had this great conversation.
So one of the things that we talked about was kind of what's coming down the pike.
And the way I see it is if you've read Project 2025, you kind of can see the chess pieces being placed, right?
We've seen our local law enforcement, you know, spouting the thin blue line and the Punisher logo and white supremacy, this, that, and the other.
We've seen the gangs in the LAPD and I'm sure many others across this country.
I'm not certainly out here saying that all cops are terrible and all cops are white supremacists, but we have seen a ton of them.
And to say, you know, it's only a few bad apples, I think, you know, it's kind of the opposite.
I think there's only a few good apples at this point.
And then we are militarizing ICE and militarizing the police force, right?
We were giving them, since the Obama days, we've been giving them surplus military equipment, which they have no business using at all or having in their possession.
And then if we look kind of at the checklist, it's like, well, isn't martial law next?
And so, yeah, I mean, we might see it.
I don't want to be a conspiracy theorist or anything, but, you know, I seem to have been on the right path so far.
Well, I imagine that I might answer one of my questions, which is if you ever think you might see the day where the police will actually protect the people against the sort of thing that ICE brings,
or will they just simply fall into step with them at some point?
I have a great answer, but somebody else can take this before I go off on it.
Anyone?
Nobody?
Nobody wants to chime in on that?
Kyle?
Go ahead, Kyle.
Well, I think there might be a small percentage, but I think that tendency to be involved in those sorts of things where there's chains of command and hierarchies,
they tend to sort of fall in and cooperate.
There might be parts of the country where that doesn't really, that doesn't work with their community standards.
Hopefully there's a lot of places in the country that have better community standards than what federal agents want to wield.
But, yeah, I think that that is entirely possible.
The use of a wider sort of federal law like martial law, it's so tempting.
I mean, you know they want to.
They're doing everything they can.
And to fast track that, to make it a reality, they're putting in place all the infrastructure for it under the auspices of this particular issue they ran on, as they put it.
But it allows so much more power if the scope of it was to widen, they would already have all of this in place.
And sadly, a lot of us were kind of alarmist in the way we felt we were sounding early on, maybe even in the previous iteration of this regime.
But it's actually a lot worse than what we were saying it would be already, straight up.
So, I don't think you're a conspiracy theorist.
It's not a conspiracy if it actually occurs, right?
You know, we can say that now.
But, you know, if we had said how bad things are now back then, nobody would have believed us.
I would have had trouble myself.
We tempered everything because we were trying to, like, meet in the middle and be all sort of, like, considerate and critical of our own thinking.
But I don't think that was as warranted as it was as we felt it was at the time.
Good points.
Well, you know, if you don't mind, just to your point, and very well said, going back to when COVID hit six years ago, right?
Almost six and a half years ago now, I was doing all kinds of research from a scientific standpoint on how it was being transmitted, how to protect yourself, what this mRNA vaccine was really, you know, is it a vaccine?
Is it not?
How does it affect your body?
All this kind of stuff.
And I was the one trying to tell people, like, this is really serious.
Like, this is going to decimate you for, like, the rest of your life.
You know, you get it.
You're going to have, like, long symptoms.
You know, you might not die from it, you know, but who knows what's going to happen.
And, you know, when Novavax came out with their vaccine, I was a huge proponent of them.
But you say these things, and the reason I'm bringing this up is, to your point, you say the stuff before it happens, and everybody goes, well, but we don't have any evidence for that yet.
And they don't want to believe what's coming down the pike until it's too late.
And that's, I think, the same thing we're seeing happening with the Trump regime and the people of this country, for example.
We've been led to believe that we're always safe, right?
Nothing's going to hit our shores.
Nothing's going to come to our doorstep.
All the horrible things happen in other countries.
And this has been trained into us for generations.
So when, you know, we see the things happening as they're happening now, and they're happening very, very quickly, things are ramping up.
Nowhere near what they're about to be, I hate to tell you.
But even what we're seeing right now, I don't think people really want to believe it.
Until it affects them personally, they're just not going to be scared of it, not going to be cognizant of it, and not really care about helping somebody else.
So many people, honestly, especially here in Texas that I've met, you say something like, well, don't you care about your fellow man, or don't you care about the people around you?
And they go, I care about me and my family.
And when it hits my doorstep, I'll do something about it.
Well, then it's too late, right?
Yeah, then you're, like, being pulled, kicking, and screaming into the street, right?
Like, it's way too late at that point.
Yeah.
People don't understand the incremental increase in temperature as they're boiling in the pot.
Joshua, do you think you've changed any minds?
Have you had any conversations where somebody said, I just never looked at it that way before, and now I support what you're doing?
I think once people understand what it really is, and it's not about the talking points, I've definitely had the, oh, now I get it kind of moments, right?
But not on the grand scheme of, like, you know, we hate you, or we hate what you're doing, or, you know, we're so against everything that you stand for, and magically I've changed their minds in a conversation.
I don't know that we can do that anymore.
I want to have rational conversations with people on both sides, by the way.
I am happy to listen to an opposing opinion, and if it's based in reality and based in facts, let's talk about it, and let's find out why you believe what you believe and why I believe what I believe, and maybe there is some common ground that we can share.
I just don't know that that's possible with the polarization that's happening right now.
And on the subject of that polarization, that brings me to Fox.
I want to know if you've ever been on Fox News.
Have they asked you to be on?
I have not been on Fox News proper.
I have been on quite a few Fox affiliates throughout this country.
Let's see, in Oakland, California, San Francisco, Vermont, El Paso.
I mean, the list goes on.
So I've been on their Fox affiliates, but that's not Fox News proper.
I don't know why they're not asking.
Maybe they don't want somebody who actually speaks truth to power.
Maybe they don't want somebody who's going to tell them what's what and push back against their lies, because I can throw facts at them all day long and dispute everything that they're saying.
I don't know, but I'm happy to go on their shows whenever they want me.
Interesting, because you've been on MSNBC.
You've been on CNN.
I imagine there's a whole lot of other networks that you've been on as well.
And I think maybe they're afraid they don't have what it takes to counter your facts with whatever it is they come up with.
Yeah, that's incredibly possible.
I mean, from Fox to Newsmax to, you know, whatever other state run media, you know, they want to have out there.
I'm happy to talk to anybody like I'm not afraid to go up against them.
So, you know, give me a call.
That's all I would say to that.
Wow.
OK, we want to try and open up the phone calls.
Joshua, sometimes this doesn't work out too well.
Sometimes we wind up getting people who talk about all kinds of other things despite our requests.
But we're going to give it a try and see if we have decent sound quality, for one thing.
802-321-4225 is our telephone number.
And if anyone is out there and wishes to be a part of the conversation, we're talking with Joshua Aaron.
So we're talking about the IceBlock app.
And if you have questions about that or thoughts, that's what we want to hear right now.
If you have other things to say, maybe we can call a little bit later on and have that conversation.
And, of course, it's the person we know is not going to do that is calling right now.
Well, let's just get it over with.
Good evening.
You're on overtime.
Go ahead, Rebel.
There's nobody there.
I don't hear anything.
You've got to plug the phone in.
Did you just hang up on?
Oh, boy.
OK.
Good evening.
You're on off the overtime.
Go ahead.
There's still nobody there, Kyle.
It's like the board isn't up.
Ah, there we go.
There we are.
OK.
Who's there?
Yes.
I'd like to mention about the IceBlock thing.
I think that, you know, there's an app that tells you when ice is coming, right?
Are you able to hear him, Joshua?
I am, yes.
OK.
I just didn't hear the...
I just heard when ice is coming and then...
I can't hear him very well.
Yeah.
OK.
We've established that you can't hear anybody on the phone, Rebel.
So what I'll do is I'll say whatever anyone else says within reason.
So your question was, does it tell you when ice is coming?
And I would imagine the answer to that would be if somebody says that ice is here and they're
within a five-mile radius and you're within that five-mile radius, you will get an alert.
Is that correct, Joshua?
That's exactly what it is.
Yeah.
It's not going to tell you that ice is predicting when ice is going to arrive somewhere.
We're simply saying, you know, here's a tool for users to report that they have seen ice
at a location and users within a five-mile radius of that location will get a notification
or it'll come up in the list if you have the app open to let you know where ice has been
sited.
So you can turn left, turn around, go home, avoid the situation.
Okay, I hope that answered your question, Rebel.
I didn't hear it.
Okay, I'm sorry.
I can't help you there.
I don't know.
Other people can hear it, but Rebel can't.
But thanks for your call, Rebel.
We're going to move on to other calls, 802-321-4225.
Usually they last 20 minutes, so this time it's, yeah, it's, but, you know, I was thinking
about this, about the app.
Isn't it basically the same thing that you could have on an app that tells you when the
ice cream man is in town?
It is.
I mean, every, and in fact, wouldn't that be a great way to market it?
Just say, hey, get the ice cream out.
It would take, it would take ice months to figure out what everybody was doing, but they're
not looking for the ice cream man.
They're looking for the ice man.
It even works.
It'd be kind of weird though.
It's like there were, there were like 10 ice cream trucks around your five-mile radius.
True.
Although, you know, their budget just went up a lot.
So, uh, I don't know.
It's a heat wave.
Yeah.
You're right.
Everybody go get your snow cones.
802-321-4225.
We don't have any calls right now.
Do we, Kyle?
Okay.
Um, any, uh, other, uh, Gila?
Go ahead.
Yes.
Um, we do have 51 people with us right now.
Um, well, 50, not counting me.
Um, we are, now we have 53.
We're very glad everyone is here with us.
Just wanted to drop a couple of things that people mentioned earlier in the discussion
on the chat.
Uh, listener Jinx, I'm assuming, says, all the tax money for legal drugs is paying for
the paramilitarization of our police forces, uh, which I think is an astute point.
And Unix Ninja, awesome, says, conspiracies aren't fake by definition, which is how they
get portrayed.
A conspiracy simply means multiple people are involved.
Um, also, Rebel was trying to tell everyone that the 2600 meetings were this Friday, not
last Friday.
Um, thank you to Rob for setting him straight.
Yeah, I think he just missed it and wants it to be this Friday, but it's not this Friday.
But some meetings are.
So because of the 4th of July, some meetings are happening.
Check your local meeting website.
And if you don't have a local meeting website, start one so that this kind of thing doesn't
get so confusing.
Um, so, um, I guess, uh, the question now is what's next?
I mean, you have the app, the app's out there.
People are using it.
Word's gotten out.
Um, is it just working on the, uh, the, the health app or is it improving this app or is
it coming up with different related apps?
Um, I'm not really looking at related apps, at least not right, right now.
Um, it is improving this app and that's what I'm kind of concentrating on 24 seven right now,
uh, making it faster, making it more stable, supporting this vast amount of users, right?
I mean, I mean, to grow that much in a week is, is tremendous.
And so the data going back and forth is huge and, um, looking at a bunch of different,
uh, options on how to do that, um, which may, uh, and again, kind of putting it in the back
of my head may allow me to bring this to Android.
And, and so I'm, I'm, I'm, I, like I said, I'm, I'm thinking about it.
I'm trying, I hear you.
Um, I, I can tell you in the next update, like somebody asked that the version number
be in there.
So that's in there now.
Uh, a couple of people asked for, uh, some languages.
So I added four new languages.
We're going to have French, Indonesian, German, and Italian in the next update, um, corrected
a little visual bug on the iPhone 15 pro, uh, where the text was wrapping, but really
I'm concentrated on how do we deliver these notifications better?
How do we do it faster?
How do we do it more accurately?
And, and, uh, and that's what I'm working on building every day right now.
Can, can the app be, um, um, modified a bit for other countries that also have similar
types of, uh, Gestapo's occasionally launching raids against them?
I, I, I suppose it probably could.
I mean, it really wouldn't have to be modified at all.
Um, you would just say, you know, this is available in this country.
So, I mean, I guess, I guess to your point, the modification would simply be only in this
country, right?
So you'd release like maybe one for Germany or one for, you know, Australia or whatever.
Like, who knows?
I, I, I don't know.
Okay.
Go ahead, Rob.
Um, there's some discussion in the chat about like where ice is happening and that, that
led me to wonder, um, I, I know you said you don't keep, uh, in individual, uh, personally
identifiable, identifiable information on the users of this app.
Um, are you keeping any statistical information on the ice sightings themselves or is it just a
flash in the pan type of thing?
No, because so all sightings are automatically deleted after four hours.
And so they're coming constantly from all over the country.
So there's not really statistics or metrics or anything like that, that I I've been collecting
or trying to analyze.
It's more just like, how can I keep this as stable as possible and make sure it's just
running for the people who need it?
I'm not trying to sell data and I don't collect any data, including metrics.
So, I mean, I get asked in almost every interview, like, you know, uh, how many users do you have
in California?
And I go, I don't fucking know.
You know, I have no idea how many I have.
So there's something really awesome about that.
I think that that's, that's the old internet spirit.
I think I put it like this.
I just don't care.
I don't care how many users I have in California or Montana or New York.
I care that there's enough people using it, that it's becoming an effective tool to protect
themselves and their communities.
That's all I care about.
Go ahead, Gaila.
So speaking of internet hacker spirit, uh, we did have a question in the chat.
Optical Phoenix asks, is the source code available?
The source code is very much not available.
And I know that this is the antithesis of the hacker community and all that kind of stuff.
I get it, but this is very much not open source because I don't want the powers that
be knowing how I'm doing what I'm doing so that they can subvert the code and then come
after our users.
So I've heard so many people calling for, well, you need to make this open source because
I don't believe that you're not collecting information.
Well, you know what?
TechCrunch independently verified without my knowledge, by the way, they put out an article
and said, we independently verified.
They're collecting nothing.
Apple has a, has the badge.
Like it's not a badge, but it's like a graph kind of graphic or whatever on the app store
page that says no data collected.
Go look for how many apps you can see that have that because they verify that stuff during
app review.
Like we collect nothing.
In fact, let's be completely transparent to your users.
When you report a sighting, here's what we get.
We get the street name, the street number, the city, the state, the zip code, the country,
which by the way, is always the United States because it's only available in the United States.
And there's a marked for deletion Boolean column.
That is literally all that's in the database.
There's nothing else.
We keep no logs at any time.
So, you know, I don't know how much safer and more anonymous I could make it than that.
Well said.
You know, I think these might be some points that other developers might take note of.
Thinking that putting your code out there is the right thing to do.
And oftentimes it is.
But it can be subverted.
I mean, how would you see that going about?
Let's say that you did put your code out there.
How could they subvert your code and get people to run that instead of what you're putting out?
Well, I mean, if all of us are in the hacker community and are coders, I think there's probably a million ways to answer that.
Right.
I probably can't even think of some of the ways that it could be done.
But, you know, I will say this.
One of the reasons that Android gave me pause rather than iOS is because you have to download the app from the Apple App Store.
If you have an iPhone, you cannot sideload.
You can't download from GitHub.
You can't download from a website.
You can't install it in any other way than from the Apple App Store.
Right.
And that means it has to go through App Review.
So that's a vetted app.
And that's why there's no malware or no nefarious apps or at least, you know, not for long if they do slip through the cracks.
On Android, you can sideload.
Right.
And so one of my concerns is and I don't even know how it might be done.
But it occurred to me that if I put out IceBlock for Android, even in the most secure way I possibly could, couldn't somebody write an app that could kind of, you know, tunnel in to IceBlock and find out if they're reporting or find out what they're doing or where their location is?
Or, you know, I am just trying to keep everybody safe.
And we are in some very, very scary times right now.
So is there a chance that something could happen?
That's good enough for me to say no.
Do you think a lot of people don't get that, that we are living in dangerous times, that they are at risk when they think they're not?
I absolutely think that because I have had pushback, especially since I tried to release an Android statement.
Just something, you know, kind of, for lack of a better word, dumbed down so that everybody could understand it.
And it was just about the push notifications, like having device IDs or having to store identifiable information.
I didn't get into all the crazy specifics, like we were just talking about sideloading or tunneling in or any of that.
And the responses were, well, I don't care if my data gets out there.
I just want the app and I want to know where Ice is.
Why aren't you protecting me?
And it's like, whoa.
You know, trust me, you care.
You just don't know that you care right now.
So, yeah, I do think that's a very prevalent thought in people who don't think it through.
So what would you say to somebody who came to you and said, you know what?
I know the risks.
I want to take those risks.
Will you allow me to do that?
No.
I mean, that's the answer.
It's plain and simple.
I am not going to be the one that's going to put you at risk with something that I write.
If you want to do it yourself, go do your own thing.
Be my guest.
Go write an app that has no security in it whatsoever and opens all your data up to whoever wants to have at it.
Let's see how far you get.
Rob, go ahead.
Joshua, I saw that you had written that fake versions of purporting to be the Iceblock app, but for Android have been popping up.
What's the game there?
Like, what are they even trying to do?
Are you serious?
People that are making fake versions?
Totally serious, yes.
There was, like, this GitHub thing that they were putting out there as Iceblock for Android and come download our code and whatever.
And users reported it to me.
I didn't even know it was out there, and that's why I put that statement out that says, hey, don't download this.
But, yeah, you know, this is what happens, right?
You know, you get an idea.
It gets big.
Somebody's going to try and do something bad to hurt people, especially when, again, we're pushing back against probably what they don't believe in.
And whether this is Russian hackers or, you know, MAGA here in the U.S. or whoever it might be.
I have no idea who this is, but I would just tell your listeners, like, this is only available right now on the Apple App Store, and it will continue to only be available on the Apple App Store for the foreseeable future.
But I'm trying.
One thing that the MAGA people were very proud of is that they claimed to have figured out how to file false reports.
But, again, as you say, it's limited to a five-mile area that you are actually in.
So, I mean, it's kind of a limited form of attack, is it not?
It's one of the most ridiculous things I've seen them do, and I love the guys.
So, perfectly candid, I was doxxed, like, three and a half weeks ago or whatever on X, right?
They put out my home address and my personal information and all this kind of stuff.
And ever since, I've had the fun time of getting death threats every single day.
We know where you are.
We're coming to get to you, you know, whatever.
So, I try to, you know, part of my staying vigilant is I'll go on X and I'll just search Ice Block and I'll look at who's posting what.
And I love these posts with, I reported 100 false sightings this morning.
And I'm thinking, did you now?
Because you can only report one sighting every five minutes.
So, maybe don't spend 500 minutes in your mother's basement.
You know, let's get out.
Let's see the world.
You know, you're probably not doing that.
But they love to say this.
Their new one is, wherever you're going, make sure you report that ice was sighted there so that the lines aren't as long.
And they're, like, talking about, like, the water park and stuff.
It's like, what are you doing?
This is so dumb.
They're using it to cut ahead a line at a water park.
That's about the mentality we're dealing with, I guess.
Look, when I was looking at the database, and I don't do this very often because, like I said, I'm not worrying about metrics or user information or any of that.
But thinking about how to make this better and improve it, I wanted to kind of go through the database and find out just how many reports were in there.
I think it was a couple days ago and went in there, and it was like 8 o'clock in the morning.
And there were, I want to say, like, 350 reports across the country, which is a lot.
350 reports that ice has been sighted is a lot right now, right?
And out of all of those, as I'm scrolling through it, I found two that just had, like, hate speech in the notes and were obviously false, two.
So they're not doing this.
And there are so many safeguards in place.
Like I said, you can only report a sighting once every five minutes.
You can only report a sighting within your own five-mile radius.
Everything's auto-deleted after four hours.
You can't type in 123 Main Street and report a sighting to kind of spam the database.
It has to be a valid address.
And you can't report the same sighting twice.
So it's not like you're going to see, and for lack of a better example, let's use 123 Main Street.
Let's say that was a valid address.
If 15 users try to report it, it's not going to happen.
Only the first one goes through and the next one say, sorry, this sighting has already been reported.
But when, you know, it expires, if they're still there, please report it again.
So all of these safeguards are in place.
And for all of their bluster and talk, it's not happening.
Is there any kind of added weight that can be given to a sighting that's been reported by multiple people as opposed to one that's just been reported by one person?
Well, again, you can't report a sighting multiple times, so I wouldn't know if multiple people were reporting it, right?
Because it's going to tell them they can't report it.
But so when you get into kind of voting or flagging or any kind of thing like that, you're now getting into moderation.
And so the minute you get into moderation, guidelines from Apple say this is a social networking app that now requires you to have a user account.
And when you have a user account, then you have to give them a way to delete that user account.
So then we're now maintaining a database with user identifiable information so that users can access it and update their profiles and change their passwords and like all this stuff that doesn't matter for IceBlock and the early warning system and leads it to be no longer 100 percent anonymous.
And so the answer, that was a very long answer to say, no.
Well, I admire your passion and sticking to that because you're going to get all kinds of pressure from people and say, oh, you can just improve by doing this.
But, you know, I totally see your point.
And this makes it simple and effective.
What I'm curious about is how much work is it for you now that it's out?
Do you have to maintain it constantly?
Is there a lot of hand-holding anywhere?
It's not so much hand-holding because there's a pretty big help file that I wrote.
I'm a big believer in explaining things to people if your listeners haven't gotten that by my rambling.
But that will explain everything.
But it's written in a way that everybody can understand it so easily.
So not really as far as like, you know, teaching or solving problems.
There have been things like I can't move the map.
And I'm like, okay, there's a little lock button right there and just two inches above your finger, tap that little, you know, question mark and read the help file and you'll know all about it.
But, yeah, not so much.
My days are now spent going, okay, what's not working properly?
For example, what, two weeks ago, users are reporting all of a sudden that nothing was updating.
Nothing was in their lists.
And they weren't getting notifications.
Like, everything was just not happening, right?
It was like a dead app.
And I'm like, what is going on here?
I come to find out that we grew so fast that Apple started rate limiting us because of the vast number of users.
So I issued a very quick update.
I stayed up literally all night.
And I rewrote the way that it was getting, you know, querying the database.
And I pushed that out the next day.
And in Apple's true fashion, they took three days to actually approve it.
But we got it out there.
And that's version 1.2.
So that solved that problem.
Now, the next one seems to be, and this isn't happening across all users, but some users aren't receiving notifications.
So, you know, what's that problem?
All the while, I'm trying to kind of revamp in a new way to do this to kind of take it off of Apple's side so that I'm more in control and able to do things faster for our users.
Let me ask you, are you able, because this is a pet peeve of mine with apps on my Android phone, I like the ability to modify the sound that it makes when it's sending an alert.
And if it's the same sound as everything else makes, I'm not going to know that my fire alarm is going off or something like that.
Do you have the ability to do that?
Or is that something you consider?
That is probably one of the best suggestions I have heard yet.
Well, thank you.
Thank you very much.
That's an awesome suggestion.
I did not even consider that as the possibility.
And of all the suggestions I've had, that one actually makes the most sense.
I'm going to put that on the list.
Like, seriously, I'm going to put that on the list.
Awesome.
Now, if only my fire alarm app could be so responsive.
But that's great to hear, because a little thing like that definitely can make a difference.
I'd like to ask you, Joshua, have you gotten many testimonials from people who say, wow, I use this and it worked and it saved my grandmother from being deported or God knows what?
I just wonder, is there a way for people to even tell you this?
The answer is, I do not encourage our users to post about, like, I'm using IceBlock and this is how I avoided this or whatever, right?
I want to keep them safe.
I want to keep them anonymous.
I don't need to know that.
But our users are incredible and they want to help other people, you know, get the app and encourage them to use it and all that.
And so they have been posting things here and there that I've seen.
And it's pretty incredible.
Very cool.
Yesterday, so a reporter from Reuters called me and they're doing kind of it's not like a documentary, but it's like an expose on what's going on in California with ice.
And he's been tasked with being on both sides for the last 30 days.
And this guy's a Mexican-American, a younger guy, amazing guy.
And he said he reached out to me because with the whole thing happening at MacArthur Park, he said literally everyone was using IceBlock when they were there.
Every phone that he looked at, everyone had IceBlock installed.
And he went, oh, my God, I got it.
I got to talk to this guy.
And that's why he reached out.
And now we're doing like this whole thing together.
So the answer is, yes, I know people are using it.
Yes, I know people are being helped by it.
But do I encourage you to come out publicly and go, hey, I used IceBlock and this saved me from something?
I don't want to encourage you to do that.
I just want you to be safe.
You know, since nobody knows what the hell that thing was at MacArthur Park on Monday, maybe you could say it was a test of our software to see how many people could use it at once.
You know, and it worked.
It was a show of force by this administration.
You know, they weren't there to arrest people.
They were there to say we can militarize these streets real quickly if we need to.
And we're here.
This is before their budget goes up a hundredfold or whatever.
Alex, go ahead.
With respect to the testimonials, I will say, though, Joshua, that if you look at the reviews in the App Store, there is a lot of effusive pros out there gushing about the efficacy of IceBlock and how it's helped people and help them and help their neighbors and communities.
So there are people out there, you know, posting about it.
And I think that's great.
Thank you for saying that.
That is true.
And I totally forgot about the App Store reviews.
I'm thinking more of like seeing posts on social media.
But you're absolutely right.
Yeah.
Go ahead, Gaila.
And that was the thing.
I was last week when we were talking about the app on the show last week, I was looking at it on the App Store and there was a fair amount of review brigading going on.
And I don't think that has necessarily dropped off completely, but it does seem to have kind of corrected again, which is nice to see.
And I will say, I downloaded, I am an iPhone user, and I downloaded it.
There have been two sightings within five miles of our home in the last four hours.
I find it also just very easy to use.
I find it super intuitive, which I really appreciate.
And I do default to having my location services on only when using the app.
So I also appreciate the push notification that told me why it was good to always have my location on.
So thank you for the clarity and the ease of use, which I definitely appreciate.
Did have a couple questions get pushed in through the chat, if you don't mind.
I know there are some things that we have discussed, but I just want to make sure that I'm asking it as the listener asked it.
So from Unix Ninja, is the push notification issue the only blocker for Android?
And if so, would something like notification polling against distributed edge workers help solve for that challenge?
So I think we talked about this.
We definitely did, yeah.
Again, it's a cool idea, but while that might be a thing, it's not what I'm looking at right now.
I'm actually thinking about a much better way to do it than that.
And it'll just be so much more robust.
But no, the answer is it's not just the push notifications.
That's kind of the statement I put out so that everybody, even the layman's, could understand it.
But I think it goes far deeper than that when you start thinking about all the ramifications of a platform like that,
which would cause you to maintain any kind of user identifiable data to do anything.
Okay.
We're speaking with Joshua Aaron, the developer of IceBlock.
And I should point out, too, Joshua's going to be at Hope in one form or another coming up next month.
And we're going to make that work somehow.
And it's another reason why you should get your ticket to Hope now, because, boy, we really need the help as far as getting attendance to go up.
We also have something new we just announced this week, the Hope Scholarship.
That's if you can't go to Hope, but you wish you could and you can afford to go,
why not help somebody who can't afford to go attend Hope for the first time and maybe change their lives?
Because so many people have said, Hope has changed my life in a good way.
All you have to do is go to our store, store.2600.com, and simply look for the Hope tickets.
You'll see one for scholarship.
What you do is you pay for a full ticket, and you indicate whether you want that to go to a student or to anybody who can't afford to go.
And we have a list of people that have already said they want to apply for scholarships, and we pair the two together.
Anonymously, if desired.
And that's how more people can go to Hope, and that's how the Hope Conference itself gets helped out to buy more tickets.
And if you can go to Hope, then by all means, get your ticket to store.2600.com.
If you want to attend Hope, but you can't attend in person, there's the virtual ticket as well.
So we have all kinds of options.
But the important thing is we need people to attend.
We have so many good speakers.
The schedule is about to be announced.
I think we have more speakers than last time, last year, which is incredible.
So, you know, we're not asking for more attendees than last time, but at least something comparable.
That would be nice, and that would enable us to continue thriving and doing things, doing more radio, doing more publishing, doing more fun things.
It's not like we spend money on this.
It's that we don't have to worry about other things, and we don't have to take on second jobs at car washes and things like that.
So hopefully everything will work out.
More details, hope.net is our email address.
All kinds of announcements being made there on a daily basis.
So before we close out for the night, Alex, I think you had something else, and anyone has any further questions for Joshua, we'll let him go because he's been with us for quite some time.
Yeah, yeah.
And I want to encourage people to call in 802-321-4225.
That's 802-321-HACK.
In the meantime, though, Joshua, am I right in understanding that the official domain for the app would be IceBlock.app?
Yes.
Okay.
All right, because I've been doing a little bit of digging while we've been talking here as well to see if any impersonations have popped up here.
Here we go.
Yeah, and in fact, surprisingly enough, though, I'm not seeing a tremendous amount of cybersquatting or impersonators just yet, but I do see that on July 1st, I believe it is, IceBlockApp.com was registered.
So that's an impersonator.
You might want to try to take that one down.
You know, we're happy to help you with that if need be.
But that, to me, could be, like, this could be a malicious distribution channel if people are able to propel and promote kind of fictitious and malicious domains, you know, maybe pushing out some kind of fake Android application that could be sideloaded and that could then compromise people.
Like, I think this is kind of dangerous if we see impersonators of IceBlock out there that go unsighted and without any kind of enforcement.
Well, has anyone dared to visit that site?
I just did.
IceBlockApp.com, the first thing I got was a notice that AdBlocker detected.
Disable your AdBlocker.
So just for the sheer hell of it, I went ahead and disabled my AdBlocker and reloaded the site.
And there are ads for commercial ice machines.
Yep.
Oh, okay.
I hadn't even thought of that.
I mean, you could totally use one of those, honestly.
Yeah, it's really, really kind of funny.
I know.
That might be helpful.
You know what a good thing is, and it might be cool to just tell your listeners, is come on the Blue Sky platform.
If you're not on there, please join us there because at IceBlock.app is the official channel of this app on Blue Sky.
And you can follow me, too.
I'm at Joshua.StealingHeather.com.
I know we haven't kind of talked about my music side, but Stealing Heather was one of the bands that I was in.
And that's why my profile is that.
Tell us something about you.
Go ahead, Rob.
Just, of course, we're off the hook radio at bluesky.social.
Yes.
Oh, nice.
So tell us something about your musical career, because you mentioned that once or twice, and I'm very curious.
Oh, sure.
So, well, in your neck of the woods, there was a band called the Rosenbergs, which was a fairly well-known power pop band in the late 90s, early 2000s.
We were the Napster tour band with Echo and the Bunnymen in the United States and Modern English in Europe, and we did all kinds of fun stuff.
And we were, as I kind of pushed, you know, in, because I was the second bass player in that band, I sort of brought the political side to it a little bit.
And, like, at Summerfest, we went with Guster and saw Fahrenheit 9-11 when that first came out, the day it came out.
And then we stopped our show in the middle of the songs, and we started talking about what was going on with our audience.
So all kinds of fun stuff there.
And then I was the front man, lead singer, guitar player for Stealing Heather, which was kind of more of a, I don't want to say arena rock, but it was more pop rock type of stuff.
I think Coldplay or Stereophonics or those kinds of bands.
And, yeah, you can see music videos on YouTube, there's still the StealingHeather.com website is still up, so you can see all kinds of photos.
And the music is all still available on Apple Music.
So you can buy the albums, you can listen to them, we're on Spotify, all kinds of different stuff.
So are you still involved?
You know, about 12 years ago, we moved to Austin, and I kind of took a break.
Wait a minute, you moved to Austin and took a break from music?
Yeah.
No one's ever done that.
It is not as musically oriented as it is purported to be, let me tell you.
We sort of threw a dart at a map coming from L.A.
I needed a break from L.A.
I was just there for so many years.
And I thought, oh, Austin, this is like the blue city in Texas, so the weather's going to be great.
I can ride my motorcycle every day of the year, and the music scene's going to be amazing.
I think it turns out, and I'm not trying to disparage anything, but just reality check,
it's like a bunch of cover bands, like college cover bands.
And I don't know how they got this live music capital of the world thing,
but I miss the musician quality in L.A. for sure.
Well, there's a lot of those bands on 6th Street, so I guess that's how they got the reputation.
Yes, there are.
But, you know, I think they'd be open to something cool and creative,
but hopefully you've got a lot of that ahead of you as well.
Well, twice now when the International Pop Overthrow has come to Austin, we headlined.
So Stealing Heather made an appearance, kind of reunited, and came out and did a show.
I did a couple of acoustic performances here and there.
Just not as much as I used to.
You know, unfortunately, you know, my wife got sick, and so I've been taking care of her,
and I've been doing kind of the home thing and the coding thing, and I'm good.
You know, I had a fantastic career for like 20 years in music, and I couldn't be more thankful for it.
But now that music has been a commodity, it's like a commodity.
It's like, you know, you spend years.
I mean, I spent four and a half years making the Your Mistake record for Stealing Heather,
which is the latest record for that band.
And, I mean, just think of how much money was spent with the label and marketing and PR
and all this kind of stuff to make this album go.
And they're selling my songs for 99 cents, you know, which, by the way, Apple takes 30 cents up, right?
So, like, we get 69 cents, and the label gets a percentage of that.
At the end of the day, I've got to pay my bills, right?
So, you know, it's just not feasible.
I'm sure Spotify comes to the rescue.
Oh, yes, yes.
What was it, Pharrell's Happy had, like, 18 million plays, and I think he got a check for 900 bucks.
That says it right there.
Hey, we have a phone call.
Let's go to the phones.
Good evening.
You're on off the cover time.
Go ahead.
Hello, this is Luwachu from Washington, D.C.
Greetings.
I was just listening.
Yeah, yeah, I was listening in.
And I can barely hear any of the other people except for Emmanuel.
Well, I don't know what to say.
I mean, we all hear it fine here, and it could be a YouTube problem.
I don't really know.
We try this every week.
We try to make it better.
We'll talk louder if that helps.
But right now, you have a question.
Go ahead.
Yes, I do have a question.
If anyone wants to forward anything to me, you'll have to go through Emmanuel, since I can only hear him.
But I was just wondering about this IceBlock app.
Why can't it just be a website that I go to?
I mean, I can just go to Firefox on my Android phone or my iPhone and report locations there.
And I'm pretty sure you can push notifications through the browser.
There's a way to do that.
All right.
Let's see what the answer is.
Go ahead, Joshua.
So the answer to that is you go to a website.
Your IP is going to be tracked in the log.
What you've done on that website, everything you've downloaded from that website, what get request is going to be logged.
Then you say, well, why can't I just report a sighting?
Okay, so let's say that you can report a sighting on the web.
So now your post request is going to be logged with your IP address.
And then you say, well, can I receive push notifications through the browser?
Sure, maybe.
But then what are we going to do?
We're going to write a Firefox extension to do that?
Like, this is not what it was designed for.
This is designed to just be an app and be an early warning system.
And I understand the idea of what you're saying.
And maybe I'll figure it out at some point down the road.
But right now my concentration is to make this app as good as it can possibly be for the iPhone.
And maybe, as I've been saying, if I can figure it out, I want to bring it to Android because I want as many users as possible.
So basically, to translate that, you should get an iPhone.
Because everything you do on the web page or on Firefox or whatever is going to be logged someplace.
And it's just not safe.
Well, I mean, it's definitely disruptive.
It was a bit low, but...
Okay, you could hear.
That's good.
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
I mean, it's unfortunate, though.
I mean, as it has been brought up before, you know, I'm sure most people in the immigrant community don't have an iPhone.
They're incredibly expensive.
I mean, Android is the cheapest one on the market.
Well, maybe the solution to that...
Go ahead, Joshua.
No, please.
Well, the solution to that is maybe to make it more available to people or to make other types of phones that do the same thing that iPhones do so that it's not risky.
Yeah, so that would be...
I mean, yes, obviously, we would love a company to come and have a secure platform like Apple has, and that would be great.
But I will say this.
It was designed, as I said before, all the way back to any device that can support iOS 18.2, right?
So that's back to the iPhone SE and the iPhone XR, which, and I'm certainly not trying to make light of any money being spent.
I am cognizant of people's finances.
But I've seen these on the secondhand market for, like, $40 or $50.
So to say that an Android device is less expensive than an iPhone, you're right if you're buying it new and you're buying the latest model.
But go on Craigslist and buy the cheapest iPhone XR you can and run IceBlock.
You can get it for $40 or $50 and keep yourself safe.
I would argue that, you know, not being detained and disappeared is maybe worth $50.
That's all I'm saying.
Yeah, absolutely.
And also a question related to this.
Are you backwards compatible with old iPhones?
And will you ever be at a stage where you have to upgrade your phone or, you know, the software won't work anymore, which happens to me all the time?
So I'm going to try my best not to have that happen.
You can set, when you're developing, you can set a minimum iOS version that you have to have.
18.2 allowed us to do some things that the older versions wouldn't allow us to do.
Okay.
And we're utilizing the latest Swift 6.
So this is, you know, all the concurrency, the strict concurrency is in this app.
It's there's nothing that could crash, basically.
And so that's why we don't have crashes.
Right.
I mean, 740,000 plus users now.
They've logged, I think, 15 crashes.
And that could be, like, from the same guy, right, that the phone's overloaded.
So this is really, really stable.
So I want to keep it at 18.2 as long as humanly possible until Apple makes me change it.
But, you know, look, I'll admit you go buy an iPhone XR, you cannot run the next iOS 26 on it.
That is a discontinued device now, according to Apple.
But you can still run 18.2 and just use it for IceBlock if you want.
You don't have to upgrade your OS, right?
So if money's an issue, I think what I'm trying to say is better to spend less money, get an older device who cares about the latest and greatest whatever.
All you care about is making sure that you know your surroundings and you can avoid potentially dangerous situations.
And I think, you know, in cases where even that is a bit much for people to afford, we can start crowdsourcing.
We can make old iPhones, you know, the face of the immigrant community where basically everybody has one.
And it's...
That's awesome.
Yeah.
What a great idea.
Disposable maybe even if, you know, it comes down to it because it's not that expensive.
I don't know.
But, Caller, thank you for bringing that up.
You've gotten us some pretty good discussion here.
What about a hardware device that could just go along with my Android phone?
I could set up some sort of hotspot on it that would allow the other device to connect to the Internet and do my ice blocking activities on that second device and have it cheaper to manufacture or purchase than an old iPhone.
All right.
I'll let Joshua answer that.
It's the last hypothetical, though.
Go ahead.
I don't see how that's any different from just buying an Android or buying any other platform because the whole point is that if you want to deliver a notification, excuse me, one second, there is a blue alert coming in on my phone that I'm trying to go away from.
Okay, there we go.
Sorry if that broke up for a second.
So, my point is this.
Any other platform, it's not just Android, so let's use a hardware device.
Or it's not just, you know, oh, well, can't we do this on a Windows desktop?
Or can't we do this here?
Or can't we do this there?
Any other platform requires maintaining a database, a private database that would have to contain some kind of user identifiable information.
And like I've repeatedly said, I'm trying to figure out a way around that issue where we can bring it to Android devices.
I'm not sure it's possible, but I'm trying.
All right, caller, we're going to have to leave it there, but thanks very much for calling in, and hopefully we can improve the sound.
All right, thank you.
All right, take care.
Alex, I'm going to give you the last word because we're almost out of time here.
Go ahead.
Well, what if that other device that the caller was referencing was simply a repurposed old iPhone SE or something that was utilizing the hotspot internet connectivity anyhow?
I mean, I think that would solve the problem, wouldn't it, Joshua?
That's an amazing idea.
It sounds eerily similar to what I said, where you could go buy an iPhone SE or an AR on the second-hand market.
Just do that.
It does sound like that, Alex.
Yeah, just do that.
But you don't necessarily have to subscribe to anything at that point, right?
Like, you don't need to be on a separate service.
No, I mean, all you need is some kind of a connection to the internet, so, you know, it's Wi-Fi or whatever, sure.
I mean, as long as you have some kind of connectivity, you're good.
Yeah, exactly.
Not sure what's going on out there, but go ahead, Gila.
To mention one thing that came up from a discussion in the chat, someone said if you're crossing a border and they see this app on your phone, will that cause a problem?
A friendly reminder, it only works in the United States, and if you are traveling out of the United States, your best course of action would probably be to temporarily uninstall the app from your phone so no one sees it there just in case and put it back when you're back in the States.
I'm going to go one step further.
I'm going to say, with what we have seen happening with people going through customs and them looking at their phones, including U.S. citizens, by the way,
my best advice is don't take your real device with you if you're going out of the country.
Get a burner phone and just do the minimal stuff that you want to do.
Don't have – I mean, look, it's not just IceBlock that's uninstalled and all of a sudden you're fine.
They have the ability to look through your social media now, right?
And they'll scare you into opening up your phone to do that, even though they don't technically have the right to do it.
They're going to scare people enough that they will do it.
And the minute they see one anti-Trump post or one thing that pushes back against anything they want to do, you have a problem.
So my best advice is leave your main device at home, the one that you're doing all your social media stuff on, the one that you're using IceBlock on.
Go enjoy yourself or do your business out of the country.
Take a burner phone with you and keep yourself safe.
You know, I agree with that completely, but I worry that most people won't be able to do that.
They won't be able to just detach themselves from the magical device that they take with them everywhere.
And what I'm wondering is, do we need to come up with something that streamlines the process of just either transferring things to another phone and then wiping it or wiping from their original phone when they're overseas about to come back and then restoring it when they get home?
It just feels like there has to be some other solution where people can just, you know, keep abiding by their bad habits and also protect themselves when they're crossing borders.
I know it's unrealistic. I know it's unhealthy, but this is what people do.
They don't listen to advice. They don't do the wise thing and they wind up hurting themselves without realizing it.
I feel like, I mean, in theory, it's a great idea. I just feel like you described feeding like a chocolate cake to a diabetic.
Yeah. Yeah. Unfortunately, they don't know they're diabetic yet.
Right.
Well, maybe this is the only way to learn. I don't know. But it's, it's scary what you say.
And we've talked about this many times. No, they should not be able to go into your social media.
How do they even get the idea they could do something like this?
And what if you don't have any social media? I'm told now, if you don't have social media, that's suspicious.
Right.
I don't know this world. I just, I'm really starting to wonder how much longer it's going to last.
Crazy. Yes. Crazy stuff.
We're going to leave it there then. On that, on that bright note, please write to us, OTH at 2600.com.
We've been talking with Joshua Aaron, the developer of the awesome app IceBlock, which you can get for your iPhone at the app store.
And I guess you want to give out information again, Joshua, for the folks listening on YouTube?
Sure. Yeah. I mean, IceBlock.app is the official website.
And if you want to join us on Blue Sky, it's at IceBlock.app.
And my handle is at Joshua.StealingHeather.com.
And yeah, connect. Ask your questions.
I try to find some time to respond to almost every one of them.
You know, try not to do too much hate posting about Android because I'm doing my best.
But yeah, we'd love to have you join us.
All right. Well, thank you for all the incredible effort you have poured into this.
It really does make a difference.
And I hope it inspires more people to do more similar type things.
It looks like, Alex, you had something else to say?
No?
I'm all good. I thought we had another phone call come in.
No, we did not.
Okay. Well, we're going to sign off for the night.
Thank you again.
And we will see you at Hope in one form or another, Joshua.
And hopefully more people will come up with ideas of ways to help preserve democracy and what's left of this country.
All right.
Again, with that cheery note, we're going to leave and back again next week.
7 o'clock on WBAI, 8 o'clock on YouTube.
Good night.
Good night.