As for the feedback on your up coming site changes, the general
consensus with my friends is that it would indeed be a sad day for
reverse engineering if you
removed the essays from your site. As a newcomer (6 months) to this
fine art - and like many, many Fravias out there - your site was the
starting point. Fravia's was
the womb from which many of us were born, and we certainly will miss
browsing through its libraries of essays. I understand your
frustration with the people who don't
appreciate the art form and do it strictly for personal gain or
whatever, but the fact remains that this is human nature, and as long
as there are humans there will be
plenty of lamers, losers, and idiots among us.
I guess my greatest concern is that you don't do anything that would
discourage the beginners. The one thing we all have in common is that
we were all beginners at
one point, and it's imperative that we embrace these fledglings,
support them, and show them the way. I agree with Prophecy in that
the tone of your writing on
septem.htm was a bit demoralizing. People are going to reverse
engineer for different reasons. Some will improve the targets by
adding functionality, while others will
simply defeat the protection for whatever reason. It is a proven fact
in our governments that you cannot legislate morality by prohibiting
anything. The right way is to
change people's hearts by teaching them and by sharing knowledge, not
by closing them off to information.
Your site is the lighthouse, the rule and guide so many ouse and
follow, and while a good house cleaning and update may be in order, it
would make the reverse
engineering community extremely sad if you were to close off the part
that is important to so many of us.
Kind regards,
DaVinci