Bombing of
Dresden in World War II -
Impact of the attack
Out of
28,410 houses in the inner city of
Dresden, 24,866 were
destroyed. An area of 15 square kilometres was totally destroyed,
among that: 14,000 homes, 72 schools, 22 hospitals, 18 churches, 5
theatres, 50 bank and insurance companies, 31 department stores, 31 large
hotels, 62 administration buildings as well as factories such as the
Ihagee camera works. In
total there were 222,000 apartments in the city. 75,000 of them
were totally destroyed, 11,000 severely damaged, 7,000 damaged, 81,000
slightly damaged. The city was around 300 square kilometres in area in
those days. Although the main railway station was destroyed completely,
the railway was working again within a few days.
The precise number of dead is difficult to
ascertain and is not known. Estimates are made difficult by the fact that
the city and surrounding suburbs which had a population of 642,000 in 1939[20]
was crowded at that time with up to 200,000 refugees[21],
and some thousands of wounded soldiers. The fate of some of the refugees
is not known as they may have been
killed and
incinerated beyond recognition in the fire-storm,
There have been higher
estimates for the number of dead,
ranging as high as 300,000. They are from disputed and unreliable
sources, such as the Reich Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda
headed by Joseph Goebbels, Soviet historians, and
David
Irving, the once
popular, but now discredited self-taught historian who retracted his
higher estimates[29].
The Nazis made use of
Dresden in their
propaganda efforts and promised swift retaliation. The Soviets also made
propaganda use of the
Dresden bombing
in the early years of the Cold War to alienate the East Germans from the
Americans and British.
The destruction of
Dresden was
comparable to that of many other German cities, with the tonnage of bombs
dropped lower than in many other areas[30].
However, ideal weather conditions at the target site, the wooden-framed
buildings, and "breakthroughs" linking the cellars of contiguous buildings
and the lack of preparation for the effects of air-raids by Gauleiter
Martin Mutschmann[31],
conspired to make the attack particularly devastating. For these reasons
the loss of life in
Dresden was higher than
many other
bombing raids during World
War II. For example Coventry, the English city which is now twinned
with Dresden, and is
often compared and contrasted with it, lost 1,236 in two separate raids in
1940. In late 2004, an RAF man involved in the raid said in an interview
on the BBC's Radio 4 that another factor was the lower-than-expected level
of anti-aircraft fire, which allowed a high degree of accuracy on the part
of the bombers.
Overall, Anglo-American
bombing of German
cities claimed around 400,000 civilian lives. Whether these attacks
hastened the end of the war is a controversial question. As acts of
retaliation, they were at best vicarious (even if entire nations are seen
as morally competent agents).