Anna's Beatnik Period

Ann Dunham's age at Barack Hussein Obama's birth, was exactly 18 years, 8 months and 7 days.

Hawaii residency requirements, and Obama SR's non-residency status, while she lived in Washington for a year from Aug 1961 to approximately Sept 1962.


What implications exist being legally-married to a British subject, with Ann being under 19, especially when Ann spent most of the Obama JR's early year's out of Hawaii with him as an infant?
 

•  Obama SR was in Hawaii at school (confirmed);
•  Obama JR was in Hawaii (reportedly with grandparents, as it was yarned previously);
•  Obama's mama was in Seattle attending school at Univ. of Washington (confirmed).

Baby Obama may have had problems with Hawaii citizenship, potentially US citizenship even if born in Washington state, as well as problems with his birth certificate as shown:

[§338-17.8] Upon application of an adult or the legal parents of a minor child, the director of health shall issue a birth certificate for such adult or minor, provided that proof has been submitted to the director of health that the legal parents of such individual while living without the Territory or State of Hawaii had declared the Territory or State of Hawaii as their legal residence for at least one year immediately preceding the birth or adoption of such child. (emphasis added)

At age 18, while married to a UK national (before Kenya as independent), Ann was not in Hawaii while taking classes at University of Washington in FALL of 1961 (confirmed), and possibly DID NOT MEET residency time requirements to declare baby Obama as a Hawaiian resident, with Ann needing a year as a Hawaiian resident. Note: Stanley Ann Dunham was born November 29, 1942.

So, here's a newly-compiled timeline:

    Summer 1960 -- Ann moved to Hawaii with Parents (exact date unknown)
    Sept 1960 -- Anna started classes at U of Hawaii (exact date: Sept. 26, 1960)
    Oct 1960 -- Anna Impregnated by Obama Sr.
    Feb 1961 -- Anna married Obama Sr. (Feb. 2, 1961)   ANN'S EXACT AGE: 18 years, 2 months, 5 days

    -- a big, six-month void --

    Aug 1961 -- Anna gave birth to Obama Jr. on Aug. 4, 1961 (reportedly in Hawaii and on that date)   ANN'S EXACT AGE: 18 years, 8 months, 7 days
    Aug 1961 -- Sighting by Susan Blake in late-August on Mercer Island, Seattle (Obama Jr. reportedly 3 weeks old)

     --
SHE'S TRAVELING FROM HAWAII TO SEATTLE, in 1961, WITH A 3-WK-OLD, only to ship the baby BACK to start classes in Seattle? Highly doubtful ...

    Fall 1961 -- Attended classes in Seattle at University of Washington (see transcripts below), but not with University of Hawaii in Spring of 1961

   
 -- possible BREAK in Hawaiian Residency status, depending on when she left Hawaii

    Fall 1961 -- a Listing for Stanley Ann Obama appears in the 1961 Polk directory at the Seattle Public Library: "Obama Anna Mrs studt h516 13th Ave. E. apt. 2"
    1961-1962 -- Anna Obama phone listing, as listed in Seattle Reverse Directory, 1961-1962: "Obama Anna Mrs EA3-3346" at "516 Villa Ria Apartments"
    Mar 1962 -- Mary Toutonghi babysat Obama Jr. at Ann Dunham (aka Anna Obama) apartment for two months (through May 1962)
    Sum 1962 -- Sighting by John W. Hunt in June-Sept 1962

    --
"I had moved to Utah for a while after high school, and I came back to Seattle in the summer of 1962. I remember visiting the World's Fair, and then stopping by Stanley Ann's apartment on Capitol Hill. It was a small apartment, upstairs. It was after June, and could have been as late as September, 1962. I visited her for half a day or so. It was after the end of the spring quarter classes, and she wasn't in classes, and didn't have a job. I recall her being melancholy at the time. I had a sense that something wasn't right in her."

    Fall 1962 -- Anna is no longer registered for classes at University of Washington
    Fall 1962 -- Obama Sr. begins school at Harvard, in Cambridge, Mass.
    Sept-Dec 1962 -- Anna moves back to Hawaii, with baby Obama, to live with parents
    Spring 1963 -- Ann Dunham resumes school back at  University of Hawaii at Manoa
    Jan 1964 -- Ann Dunham files for divorce in Hawaii Court
    Mar 1964 -- Divorce is granted (Obama SR does not respond to divorce notice in Boston)

Exhibits:  Ann Dunham's Transcript summaries:  http://atlasshrugs2000.typepad.com/atlas_shrugs/2008/10/how-could-stanl.html:

"The University of Hawaii at Manoa is only able to provide the following information for Stanley Ann Dunham: (Dates of attendance):
   
    Fall 1960 (First day of instruction 9/26/1960)

    Spring 1963 - Summer 1966

"Ms. Stanley Ann Dunham was enrolled at the University of Washington for":

    Autumn 1961
    Winter 1962
    Spring 1962

See more in: The Myth of Barack Obama's Early Life - by Michael Patrick Leahy -- The Myth of Barack Obama's Early Life - Cached

One final thought:

In the 1964 Divorce (1964 Obama Divorce papers), on Pg 2, Section I, Ann FALSELY attested on Jan. 20, 1964 that she "is now and for more than TWO years past has been a resident of Honolulu, City and County of Honolulu, State of Hawaii." At least TWO years prior would be Jan 20, 1962, when she CLEARLY had been in Washington state, with baby Obama, until as late as September 1962.

Post Reply | Private Reply | To 282 | View Replies

This story disappeared into oblivion because it went to press on Inauguration Day. But it offers information, and additional information to the timeline. Summary: Mary Toutonghi, a speech pathologist currently operating a private clinic in Soldotna, was living in Seattle during the early 1960s with an 18-month daughter and a husband attending Seattle University. Barack Obama's mother was her neighbor. Toutonghi needed extra pin money, and Stanley Ann Durham needed a babysitter. Thus began the commercial relationship.

She watched Obama a few times a week, for about three hours at a time. Toutonghi doesn't remember how much Dunham paid her, but she does remember what Barack Obama was like at the time. It tells more about Ann Dunham (mom) and baby Obama in Seattle. It also lends additional credence to being born in Canada, versus Ann Dunham (mom) hopping back and forth in the early 60's between Seattle and Hawaii on the airlines with a baby Obama (There should be aircraft manifest archives in a library or depository if true ...):
Tuesday, January 20, 2009
Obama baby sitter awaits new era — Soldotna woman eager for former charge’s reign
By Jenny Neyman
Redoubt Reporter

On Tuesday, supporters of President-elect Barack Obama looked forward to watching him take the oath of office with a sense of excitement, pride and hope for the future. Mary Toutonghi, of Soldotna, was prepared for that and another sensation: Remembrance of the 44th president as a 7-month-old baby.

Toutonghi used to baby-sit President Obama when she was neighbors with his mother.

Toutonghi was living in Seattle at the time, in the early 1960s. Her husband was going to school at Seattle University, and she was a stay-at-home mom with their 18-month-old daughter.

They lived in a three-story house that had been converted into three inexpensive apartments. Toutonghi and her family lived in the basement apartment, and Ann Dunham — Obama’s mother — lived in the apartment directly upstairs.

Dunham attended night classes a few days a week at the University of Washington, and needed someone to take care of her son.


“The time was available and we were all struggling students. She needed a baby sitter and I said ‘Sure,’” Toutonghi said.

She watched Obama a few times a week, for about three hours at a time. Dunham paid her, but she doesn’t remember how much, Toutonghi said.

“I remember his being very large and very curious and very alert. I don’t remember him fussing, but that doesn’t mean anything. Saying he never fussed is like saying he’s not real. But I don’t remember any undue fussing at all,” she said.

Being a struggling young mother herself, in the tumultuous dawning of the 1960s, no less, Toutonghi said she doesn’t remember many specifics about Dunham.

“I was so engrossed in myself at the time,” she said.

But the circumstances of a young mother living, attending school and raising a baby alone stuck in Toutonghi’s mind.

“It was a tough situation, as far as I knew,” she said. “She was 19, she’d promised her parents that she was going to finish college, even through she’d married. I’m presuming her parents were paying for the schooling — nobody had any money at the time.”

Dunham met Barack Obama Sr., a foreign student from Nyang’oma Kogelo in Kenya, Africa, when she was a freshman at the University of Hawaii at Manoa. They married on Feb. 2, 1961, and Barack Obama II was born Aug. 4, 1961, when Dunham was 18.

Dunham left school to take care of the baby, and returned to Seattle while Obama Sr. finished college in Hawaii and left for graduate school at Harvard University.

“It was interesting, and I don’t know why she was going to school in Seattle and he was in Hawaii at the time. She had told me at one point that because of her husband’s post in the tribe he was going to have to go back to Kenya and marry a black woman, as well. It was a whole different world, so she was accepting of that and hoping she could get back to him soon,” Toutonghi said.

Later, Dunham moved back to Hawaii with her son and filed for divorce from Obama Sr. in 1964.


By that time, Toutonghi had long since moved on to the next chapter in her life. She baby-sat for Dunham for two months, then she and her husband bought a house in the Government Hill section of Seattle and moved there, before moving to Alaska in 1977. She had a long career as a speech pathologist. She’s retired from the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District and has a private clinic in Soldotna.

She didn’t have cause to think about her former charge until 2004, when she came across his first book, “Dreams from My Father.” Then she saw he was the keynote speaker at the Democratic National Convention in 2004.

“Since I found the book, ‘Dreams from My Father,’ when it was first published, then when I was working on the 2004 presidential campaign and realized he was the convention speaker, it blew me away. And then this,” she said.

“I keep thinking of the six degrees of separation, that thing. I’ve known some unusual people in my time, but this was different.”

Toutonghi said she went to school in California with Bob Hope’s kids.

“We were in the neighborhood, essentially. I was not one of the elite group members, by any means, but I remember getting an award once with he and Dorothy in the audience,” she said.

As famous-people stories go, that’s noteworthy. But nowhere near as much as having changed the future president’s diapers.

“It was just mind-boggling to me when he did that Democratic convention, and then was like, ‘Huh,’” she said.

Toutonghi said she often wondered what happened to Dunham, who became Ann Dunham Soetoro after a later marriage, and died of ovarian cancer in 1995.

“We talked, but I can’t say, if I had been really strong friends I would have kept up the relationship. It was interesting to me as I read that book, his first book, I was thinking of his mother, then finding out she had died I felt very badly. I had meant to try to contact her through the publisher, but I didn’t get around to it. It was one of those things,” she said.

Toutonghi said her daughter asked if she had voted for President Obama because she had once baby-sat him.

“I said no. I felt that he had a concern for people as a whole,” she said. “As I thought of the books and things I had read about him and what I knew of that period of time, I think he was very aware of ordinary people and people who were trying really hard to make it. His mother definitely had spoke in terms of concern for people, and I just had the feeling that he must have carried some of that through, and it seems to be turning out that way. I listened to some of the speeches he had made today and he has an awareness of what it’s like to struggle to achieve something.”

She was looking forward to seeing President Obama take office, and not just for the thrill of 40 years-removed fame.

“I just think we’ve been through eight years of hell,” Toutonghi said, referring to the war in Iraq, mounting national debt and the country’s downward spiral into economic recession during President Bush’s administration.

She’s hoping the alert, inquisitive boy she once took care of now takes care of the country.

“I think he’s got a horrible job ahead of him, but he seems to be taking it in stride,” she said.